Mini Pepperoni Air Fryer Pizza Bagels

These Mini Pepperoni Air Fryer Pizza Bagels will bring back the nostalgic after-school snack you had growing up! Bring back childhood memories by quickly whipping up a batch.

This post may contain affiliate links. That means if you click and buy, I may make a commission at no cost to you. Please see my full disclosure policy for more details.

---

Why You’ll LOVE Mini Pepperoni Air Fryer Pizza Bagels

Pizza bagels were a freezer staple for a reason! They are easy to make, taste delicious, and actually pretty filling.

You are going to love these Air Fryer Pizza Bagels because they will fill you with childhood nostalgia. By making these you’ll be transported back those summer afternoons where you were hungry for lunch and excited to know today you were having PIZZA BAGELS!

Now, nostalgia is great and all, but maybe we had different experiences. If you’ve never had a pizza bagel and are excited to make your own homemade version you will be happy to know they are incredibly quick and easy. That means you’re just minutes away from chomping down!

When to Make These Air Fryer Pizza Bagels

Growing up the classic frozen pizza bagels were my go-to after school snack or meal in the summer months. I still stand by these being perfect for these times!

So, you can have these as a quick lunch, an afternoon snack, dinner, fourth meal (if you participate), or a midnight snack! Heck! Have a batch for breakfast! All foods can be enjoyed at any time of the day.

When do you plan on having these pizza bagels? Tell me in the comments below!

Ingredients You’ll Need

The great thing about this recipe is that you are only a few simple ingredients away from these delicious Mini Pepperoni Air Fryer Pizza Bagels!

• Mini bagels
• Pizza sauce
• Shredded mozzarella cheese
• Mini pepperoni

How to Make Air Fryer Pizza Bagels

Start by preheating your air fryer! It’s just the absolute WORST when you are ready to bake your pizza bagel but then have to wait for the air fryer to preheat! So, go turn on your air fryer and heat it to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.

The best way to make Air Fryer Pizza Bagels are by assembling them on a plate then carefully placing them in your air fryer. This way you aren’t creating a disaster in your air fryer to have to be cleaned afterwards.

Slice your mini bagel in half, add your pizza sauce to both sides, top with shredded cheese, then add your pepperoni! Pop these in the air fryer and allow the machine to work its magic. After 3-5 minutes you’ll have your delicious Mini Pepperoni Air Fryer Pizza Bagels!

Expert Tips and Tricks

Although this recipe isn’t too difficult, tips and tricks are always useful in making a recipe easier or more tasty!

• Don’t use frozen ingredients. This may seem like a no-brainer, but using a frozen bagel or cheese will result in uneven cooking.
• If you are using any toppings beyond mini pepperoni, be sure to cut them small. A mushroom that would be appropriate for a regular sized pizza will be way too big for these mini versions.
• Add some seasonings! You can add garlic powder or Italian seasoning on your bagel or on the sauce for some additional flavor.
• Make your pizza bagel on a plate then add into the air fryer. This avoids a mess in the air fryer!

After making yours did you come up with any tips and tricks? Let me know in the comments down below. I’d love to improve my technique as well!

Frequently Asked Questions

Pizza bagels are fun and can be made by kids and adults alike. If you have a question, you may find your answer below. If you’ve got more questions leave them in the comments down below and I will be sure to get you an answer!

What temperature should my air fryer be at?

The ideal temperature would be 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Be sure to allow your air fryer to preheat then add in your pizza bagels!

How long should I cook my mini pizza bagels?

It doesn’t take long to cook mini pizza bagels! Depending on how crisp you like your pizza bagels, 3-5 minutes is all it will take.

Can I use frozen bagels?

You can thaw your mini bagels and then use them. If you add your toppings to a frozen bagel they will bake unevenly and result in a cold bagel and overcooked toppings!

Substitutions and Alterations

The options are endless for pizza bagels! Just like pizza, everyone will have their preferences. This recipe can be altered to accommodate them.

• Chopped mushrooms
• Sausage
• Bacon bits
• Pineapple
• Diced peppers

Instead of plain mini bagels you can go for an asiago version for some extra cheesy goodness.

A Word From a Registered Dietitian Nutritionist

At first thought Mini Pepperoni Air Fryer Pizza Bagels don’t sound like the best thing for you but let’s break it down a bit. The bagel provides carbs, the sauce gives some veggies and dietary fat, and the cheese and pepperoni have protein and dietary fat. You’ve got all the components covered. Depending on your toppings you could even be adding in some fruit!

Another viewpoint is the nostalgia factor. Food is more than just fuel. It is an experience. It can be a part of memory making and the reason for thinking back to a memory. That’s exactly what they can do. If a food puts a smile on your face because you think of a good memory, it’s good for you.

Craving More?

If you give this Mini Pepperoni Air Fryer Pizza Bagels recipe a taste be sure to leave a 5-Star rating and comment down below! This really supports me and entices others to also give the recipe a go!

You can also share a photo of your creation by tagging me on Instagram! I’d love to see how it turned out!

You may also want to try and read these other posts:

• High Protein Vegetarian Snacks You’ll Love
• Healthy Buffalo Chicken Dip with Greek Yogurt
• Low Sodium Snacks- Dietitian Approved!
• Easy Buffalo Chicken Flatbread with Ranch

Mini Pepperoni Air Fryer Pizza Bagels Recipe

Pin NOW to SAVE for later!